Loading... Please wait...

Blog

Precious Gemstone VS Semi-Precious Gemstones

Posted on

Precious Gemstones VS Semiprecious Gemstones

You may occasionally come across the terms ‘precious’ or ‘semiprecious’ in relation to gemstones and wonder what the differences are. On the other hand, you may be quite familiar with these terms. In either case, I’ll give a little background on the terms and then I’ll share my thoughts on why I feel the use of these terms are obsolete and should no longer be used.

WHAT IS A GEMSTONE?

Luxury Gemstones for Jewelry

Gemstones are either minerals or organic matter (derived from plants or animals) that have been cut, polished and fashioned for use in a jewelry piece. We use them in our luxury gold gemstone jewelry. Pearls, amber, coral and ivory are the most well-known organic gemstones. The vast majority of gemstones are minerals; natural, inorganic materials with specific chemical compositions, most of which have a characteristic crystalline structure. In order to be classified as a gem, a mineral must be:

Beautiful - something that has visual appeal

Durable - a combination of hardness (how well it resists scratching and abrasion), toughness (the ability to withstand breaking, chipping and cracking) and stability (how well it resists the effects of light).

Rare - Of 3000+ minerals currently known to man, only about 100 are identified as gems.

HOW DID THE TERMS PRECIOUS AND SEMIPRECIOUS COME ABOUT?

2000 years ago, students of gemology classified gems purely by color. For many centuries, ruby and red spinel were classified as the same gemstone due to their similarity in color. In the 14th century, the Imperial State Crown of England featured a 170 carat gemstone known as the Black Prince’s Ruby, which is actually a red spinel. Over time, gemologists discovered the two gemstones are chemically different. In the mid-1800s, as more was being learned about the differences among gemstone varieties and species, they were divided into two categories: precious and semiprecious stones. The separation was based on value differentiation. 

Ruby and Diamond Earrings in 18kt White Gold Spinel and Diamond Cocktail Ring 14kt yellow Gold

Four gemstones were designated as precious:

Diamond

Emerald

Ruby

Blue Sapphire

They were the most expensive and sought after stones at the time. All other varieties and species of gems were classified as semiprecious. These designations grew in popularity over the years, became quite ingrained in the jewelry trade and are still used today.

WHAT’S WRONG WITH THESE TERMS?

According to Webster’s Dictionary:

Precious is defined as: “of great value or high price”

The prefix semi means: “to some extent; partial; incompletehaving some of the characteristics of”. Semisweet chocolate is ‘slightly sweetened’ and something that’s semiautomatic is ‘not fully automatic’.

Semiprecious is defined as a “gemstone that is of less commercial value than a precious stone; fairly valuable; having somewhat less value than a precious stone.”

So, using a similar train of thought, if 150 years ago there were only 3 ice cream flavors, chocolate, vanilla and strawberry and 90% of total ice cream sales were chocolate and vanilla, could they have been designated ‘delicious ice creams’ and strawberry ‘semidelicious ice cream’? As the numbers of flavors increased over time, would all the new flavors (including my favorite, Cherry Garcia) be lumped into the category of ‘semidelicious ice creams’?

WHAT’S THE CURRENT SITUATION?

What does ‘precious’ mean in today’s gem market? Does it mean valuable, rare, beautiful or desirable?

Are diamonds, emeralds, rubies and sapphires more valuable, rare, beautiful or desirable than all the other gemstones on the market? Some of the problems with calling some stones "precious" based on these factors include:

Value – When looking at 2019 wholesale asking prices for a sampling of the more popular gemstones used in jewelry, diamond and ruby lead the pack in terms of price per carat. Fine grade ruby and blue sapphire are difficult to find, with lower quality goods in adequate supply. In total number of carats sold, blue sapphire remains the top seller in the world’s colored stone markets. However, Paraiba tourmaline and Alexandrite have surpassed blue sapphire and emerald in cost per carat for fine material. Cuprian tourmaline and some black opal are comparably priced to fine emerald. This clearly shows that so-called ‘semiprecious’ gemstones can compete price-wise in the same market space as at least 2 of the ‘precious’ gemstones.

Rarity - Many "semiprecious" stones are also more rare than precious stones. Red beryl, tanzanite, demantoid and tsavorite garnet and numerous other gems are all found in a fewer number of locations and produced in smaller quantities than any of the "precious" stones. They are incredibly rare in comparison, but that does not earn them the term "precious."

Beauty and Desirability - Beauty and desirability are both properties that are based upon the opinion of the observer. Each year I attend the American Gem Trade Association GemFair to source a portion of my colored gemstone needs. I look at thousands of colored gemstones and carefully inspect hundreds of individual stones. When I look at colored gemstones, the main factors I look for is vibrancy of color and how the stone’s cut and finish displays the color. While I’ve seen some beautiful so-called precious stones, I would put some garnets, tourmalines, opals, spinels, Oregon sunstones and zircons up against any of them for use in my jewelry. On the other side, I’ve seen some lower graded ‘precious’ gemstones that I wouldn’t put in a jewelry piece of mine if you gave it to me for free.

CONCLUSION

The terms "precious and semiprecious" are outdated, arbitrary and meaningless. In the early days of gemology, when the understanding of properties of different species and varieties of gemstones was in its infancy, these terms provided buyers and sellers some framework for guidance. With today’s scientific study of gemology and the ability to retrieve information quickly, we can easily track and make educated gemstone purchase decisions without such simplistic and misleading terms as precious and semiprecious. For those reasons, the terms should be eliminated. In my opinion, all natural gemstones are precious! When buying gemstone jewelry, you should focus on the gemstone’s beauty and appeal, how it suits your intended use and if it is priced in a manner you’re willing to pay. These considerations are infinitely more meaningful that a gemstone’s designation as ‘precious’ or ‘semiprecious’.

SILVER USE IN JEWELRY

Pure silver possesses a unique, lustrous white color, which makes it very desirable for use in jewelry. The alloy known as sterling silver originated in continental Europe around the 12th century, well before white gold was created in the 19th century and before platinum could be produced in commercial quantities. You can check out how silver is combined with gold [...]

Read More »


PLATINUM USE IN JEWELRY

Platinum’s natural greyish-white color is similar to white gold, but not as silvery-white. Platinum is among the rarest and most expensive metals in the world. It is also one of the strongest and most durable metals known to man.Platinum’s popularity for use in jewelry comes from its beautiful luster, resistance to tarnishing and its ability to move with force rather [...]

Read More »


GOLD USE IN JEWELRY

Gold has been used since antiquity for jewelry, coinage, sculpture, vessels and as a decoration for buildings, monuments and statues. As early as 3000 BC, gold jewelry was worn by both men and women in Mesopotamia (today mostly Iraq, but also parts of Syria, Iran and Turkey). Gold purity or fineness (the amount of pure gold contained in the product) [...]

Read More »


WHAT ARE PRECIOUS METALS?

 Precious metals are those metals in the Periodic Table which are rare and possess high economic value. Eight Periodic Table elements are considered precious metals: gold, silver and the six metals comprising the platinum group of metals (platinum, palladium, ruthenium, rhodium, osmium and iridium). The six platinum group metals have similar chemical and physical characteristics, are neighbors on the [...]

Read More »


WHAT IS A METAL ALLOY?

Metals are either elements (shown in the Periodic Table) or alloys. The major precious metal elements are gold (Au), silver (Ag) and platinum (Pt). While jewelry can be made from each of these elements in its pure form, jewelry makers found they are not ideal choices for jewelry. Pure gold and pure silver are quite soft and malleable which causes [...]

Read More »


WHAT IS VERMEIL?

Vermeil, pronounced "vehr-MAY," simply put is a metal product created by coating sterling silver with gold. In the US, to be designated as vermeil an item must be: Made using sterling silver as the base metalThe gold portion must be of reasonable durability and a minimum of 2.5 microns thickThe gold must be 10 karats or higher in fineness. Most [...]

Read More »


PRECIOUS METALS WE USE IN OUR JEWELRY

The primary precious metal alloys comprising our current jewelry inventory are gold, sterling silver and sterling silver vermeil. A microscopic layer of another precious metal, rhodium, is plated onto many of our sterling silver and white gold jewelry pieces. Rhodium is used to cover any tinge of yellow which remains from the natural gold color and gives the item an ultra-white appearance. Rhodium also accepts [...]

Read More »


Inspirations for My Jewelry Designs!

Inspiration for each of my fine gemstone jewelry designs usually occurs one of three ways. Something I encountered in everyday life triggers a design idea, I see that rare gemstone which captures my imagination, or a brainstorming session with a family member gets the creative juices flowing. Here's a little behind the scenes look at the process I went [...]

Read More »


Will Our Fine Gemstone Ring Fit You

You’re going to learn in this blog that the best way to start is by measuring your ring size using ring gauges, as pictured towards the middle of the blog. If you’re located in the US, we are happy to provide you with a complimentary set of these ring gauges. Just email info@100eastfinejewlery.com or call 812-202-2143. We’re happy to send [...]

Read More »